Janna Pugh

SEO Specialist · Five9

Key takeaways

3:05AI tools like ChatGPT work best for back-office SEO tasks—competitor research, interlinking strategy, and product categorization—but should not be trusted to generate user-facing content like titles, descriptions, or body copy.
14:17Traditional SEO (technical optimization, content building, link building) remains mandatory to get content indexed by Google, even though AI Mode and AI Overviews generate links that receive almost no clicks.
16:19Clickthrough rates from AI Overviews have dropped significantly; multiple studies show Google is not sharing data on this decline despite publisher complaints.
20:25Agentic AI and one-click conversion experiences (like Google's upcoming shopping integrations) represent the future; SEOs must adapt to optimize for conversions within AI agents rather than blue-link traffic.
31:36SEO professionals remain essential because they provide strategic reasoning, analysis, and fact-finding that AI alone cannot deliver; success requires working with AI, not against it.

Questions Janna Pugh answered

How are generative AI tools like ChatGPT, Google Gemini, and Claude changing day-to-day SEO tasks, and what benefits or pitfalls have you observed?

AI excels at automating back-office work like competitor research and interlinking strategy but cannot be trusted for user-facing content due to hallucinations and inaccuracy. Traditional writer expertise still outperforms AI-generated copy.

The AI reality: Navigating strategic shifts in SEO2:03 · with Thomas Phillips, Barry Schwartz

How should SEO professionals balance the efficiency of AI-generated content with the need to maintain quality, uniqueness, and E-E-A-T?

SEOs should reject pure AI shortcuts for content creation; instead, use AI for outlines and ideation while keeping human writers responsible for final copy. Taking shortcuts violates user trust and risks long-term rankings.

The AI reality: Navigating strategic shifts in SEO8:10 · with Thomas Phillips, Barry Schwartz

Which parts of SEO can be successfully automated by AI, and where do you draw the line between helpful automation and errors?

Automation works for back-office tasks like technical audits and categorization, but user-facing elements like meta titles and body copy require human oversight. Full automation of content creation is risky and can cause traffic drops.

The AI reality: Navigating strategic shifts in SEO10:07 · with Thomas Phillips

With AI Overviews appearing on roughly 30% of US search queries, what strategic adjustments should SEOs make?

Traditional SEO remains necessary to index content that Google uses for AI Overviews, but clickthrough rates from these experiences have dropped dramatically. SEOs must focus on commercial intent keywords and brand positioning rather than expecting traffic from AI-driven results.

The AI reality: Navigating strategic shifts in SEO14:17 · with Barry Schwartz, Thomas Phillips

What are the implications of Google's agentic AI, deep search, and AI-driven shopping experiences for SEO?

Agentic AI offers potential for one-click conversions without directing users to websites. Deep search appeals to niche researchers but may not drive traffic. SEOs should explore integrating directly with Google's agents for conversions.

The AI reality: Navigating strategic shifts in SEO19:24 · with Barry Schwartz

Schedule a demo